Car Myth Biting the Dust

As this article by Joel Kotkin reports, the idea that cars were on the way out is a leftist dream yet realized, and—if the private car loving public has anything to say about it and they do—probably never realized.

An excerpt.

For a generation, the car has been reviled by city planners, greens and not too few commuters. In the past decade, some boldly predicted the onset of “peak car” and an auto-free future which would be dominated by new developments built around transit.

Yet “peak car,” like the linked concept of “peak oil” has failed to materialize. Once the economy began to recover from the Great Recession, vehicle miles traveled, sales of cars, and particularly trucks, began to rise again, reaching a sales peak the last two year. Instead, it has been transit ridership that has stagnated, and even fallen in some places like Southern California.

Demographics — notably the rise of the millennial generation — were once seen as the key to unlocking a post-car future. Yes, younger people have been slower to buy cars than their predecessors, much as they have been slow to get full-time jobs, marry or buy homes, but more are now driving, so to speak, the car market, representing the largest share of new automobile buyers.

Convenience can’t be banned

The persistence of personal transportation has little to do with the much hyped “love affair” with the automobile but convenience and access to work. Simply put, with a few notable exceptions, Americans live in increasingly “dispersed regions.” Transit works brilliantly, as Wendell Cox and I demonstrated recently in a paper for Chapman’s Center for Demographics, to downtown San Francisco and a few other “legacy” urban centers, notably New York which accounts for a remarkable 40 percent of all transit commuting in the United States.

Yet, overall, 90 percent of Americans get to work in cars. Access to jobs represents a key factor. University of Minnesota research shows that the average employee in 49 of the nation’s 52 major metropolitan areas can reach barely 1 percent of the jobs in the area by transit within 30 minutes while cars offer upwards of 70 times more access. This practical concern does much to explain why up to 76 percent of all work trips remain people driving alone.

What the future may hold

Cars are rapidly becoming both more flexible and environmentally friendly. Today, autos produce roughly a quarter of all U.S. GHG emissions but emit, according to the EPA, 75 to 90 percent less pollutants than in 1970. Years of emission controls and technological improvements have helped make the automobile, on average, a less conspicuous source of GHG. The EPA projects a 12 percent decline in CO2 emissions from cars while miles traveled increases 11 percent from 2015 to 2025. The U.N. now deems cow emissions more “damaging to the planet” than CO2 from cars.

Perhaps the biggest shift may be to electric cars. China, the world’s biggest car market, plans to allow only electric vehicles in the future. This transition will make cars cleaner, although the high energy cost of producing batteries with their rare metals may create major environment problems. It will also radically boost demand for electricity, mostly powered by coal and other fossil fuels. With nuclear power off the agenda in most western countries, and renewables far short of reliably providing the necessary extra juice, electric cars could produce sweet music to the natural gas industry, which accounts for more than six times as much of electricity generation than wind and solar combined and has been the driving force for U.S. GHG emission declines.

About David H Lukenbill

I am a native of Sacramento, as are my wife and daughter. I am a consultant to nonprofit organizations, and have a Bachelor of Science degree in Organizational Behavior and a Master of Public Administration degree, both from the University of San Francisco. We live along the American River with two cats and all the wild critters we can feed. I am the founding president of the American River Parkway Preservation Society and currently serve as the CFO and Senior Policy Director. I also volunteer as the President of The Lampstand Foundation, a nonprofit organization I founded in 2003.
This entry was posted in Environmentalism, Transportation. Bookmark the permalink.